Rotten Tomatoes
Movies Tv shows RT App News Showtimes
Publications list

ForReel Movie News And Reviews

ForReel Movie News And Reviews is not a Tomatometer-approved publication. Reviews from this publication only count toward the Tomatometer® when written by the following Tomatometer-approved critic(s): Matthew Simpson, Thomas Stoneham-Judge.

Prev Next
Rating Title | Year Author Quote
3/5
People We Meet on Vacation (2026) Matthew Simpson People We Meet On Vacation is a fine movie, but that's all it is. It's never challenging, surprising, or remarkable in any way, except maybe for the aforementioned attractive people.
Posted Jan 21, 2026  Edit critic review
4.5/5
The Son and the Sea (2025) Thomas Stoneham-Judge Watching these characters navigate their dynamics with each other is why I am eager to return to this movie over and over again.
Posted Sep 22, 2025  Edit critic review
4/5
Modern Whore (2025) Matthew Simpson [Modern Whore] breaks open doors and gives viewers an entertaining and enlightening look inside the world of sex work, and the film is entirely successful thanks to fun staging and Werhun’s engaging screen presence.
Posted Sep 13, 2025  Edit critic review
Inside Man (2006) Matthew Simpson Inside Man remains one of the best-cast and slickest heist films of the 2000s
Posted Aug 26, 2025  Edit critic review
2/5
The Bearded Girl (2025) Matthew Simpson Not the kind of movie that anyone is going to get their big break from, but it is the kind of movie that an exec might watch and say, "get me that woman for my next project". That's not nothing, not enough for anyone to go out of their way to see.
Posted Aug 01, 2025  Edit critic review
3/5
The Well (2025) Matthew Simpson The Well might tread on some familiar territory, but its well-defined characters –particularly the performance by McCarthy as the antagonist – and well-thought-out world make it perhaps not unique, but entirely believable.
Posted Jul 25, 2025  Edit critic review
2.5/5
Horsegirls (2025) Matthew Simpson Horsegirls' basic plot and structure may not be unique, but the characters that tell it are. It is perhaps too cliché to be great, but the characters will stick with you, and their depictions will hopefully bring some new perspective.
Posted Jul 21, 2025  Edit critic review
5/5
Superman (2025) Matthew Simpson This is [Gunn] asserting that hope wins over despair, that trust in your friends always pays off, and that kindness is punk rock. Gunn gets Superman in a way that this critic has been waiting for for years.
Posted Jul 19, 2025  Edit critic review
3.5/5
Birthright (2025) Matthew Simpson Writer and director Zoe Pepper has created an excellent dark comedy that borders at times on being a straight up horror film.
Posted Jul 16, 2025  Edit critic review
4/5
Inside (2024) Matthew Simpson Each of the characters has to confront who they are and whether they are worthy of even the promise of redemption, and has the guts not to offer any easy answers.
Posted Jul 14, 2025  Edit critic review
2/5
The Electric State (2025) Matthew Simpson The Electric State is a slog to watch, and frustrating not only because it's poorly executed, but because the film is full of good ideas and incredible performers, yet the Russos can't seem to conjure up anything of interest out of it all.
Posted Jul 12, 2025  Edit critic review
4/5
A Different Man (2024) Matthew Simpson When our circumstances change, do we rise to the occasion or falter? Do we become the people we hoped to be or remain the same? A Different Man is a film that explores this idea in a logical extreme.
Posted Jul 12, 2025  Edit critic review
4/5
September 5 (2024) Matthew Simpson the story it is telling is of the newsroom rather than the events themselves. It's a fine line to walk, especially in 2024, but Fehlbaum does an admirable job walking it.
Posted Jul 12, 2025  Edit critic review
3.5/5
The Greatest Hits (2024) Matthew Simpson It knows where it's going, and it gets there at speed. It is a touch predictable, but the novel approach to time travel and the performances from Boyton and Min make it worthwhile if you're willing to vibe with it.
Posted Jul 12, 2025  Edit critic review
4/5
Civil War (2024) Matthew Simpson It's a stern warning to anyone who has fantasised about taking up arms against their fellow Americans, no matter which side they are on. Civil War is a film that will show you precisely what that might look like and how horrifying it actually is.
Posted Jul 12, 2025  Edit critic review
4/5
The Marvels (2023) Matthew Simpson It's bright, colourful and fun; it doesn't take itself too seriously and isn't afraid to gloss over parts of the back story that don't matter. It's a great time at the movies.
Posted Jul 12, 2025  Edit critic review
4/5
The Killer (2023) Matthew Simpson If the story of The Killer is one of a man doing his best not to let his emotions get in the way of his professionalism after a rare miss in his storied career, it's hard not to think that Fincher is telling his own story here.
Posted Jul 12, 2025  Edit critic review
4.5/5
Anatomy of a Fall (2023) Matthew Simpson Director Justine Triet's Anatomy of a Fall not only continues this trend of crafting captivating courtroom drama, but it’s one of the best audiences have seen in some time.
Posted Jul 12, 2025  Edit critic review
3/5
The Creator (2023) Matthew Simpson The Creator is a well-intentioned misfire, but it's one worth seeing not only to decide for yourself, but to support filmmaking with purpose, and that isn't already connected to a major franchise.
Posted Jul 12, 2025  Edit critic review
4/5
The Royal Hotel (2023) Matthew Simpson The Royal Hotel is a masterclass in tension-building. Green placing these characters in an inescapable place is one thing, but she is also intelligent enough to know that the scariest thing she could do is let these men be the men they are.
Posted Jul 12, 2025  Edit critic review
2.5/5
birth/rebirth (2023) Matthew Simpson The film often hints at and alludes to commentary on the societal notion that motherhood is an essential and defining part of womanhood, but never commits to broaching the topic in a bold or thought-provoking way.
Posted Jul 12, 2025  Edit critic review
5/5
Oppenheimer (2023) Matthew Simpson Oppenheimer is a feat of filmmaking and might have the most on its mind of any of Nolan's films about the state of the world, what knowledge can bring, who owns that knowledge and what the powerful do with the things we create.
Posted Jul 12, 2025  Edit critic review
2.5/5
Gladiator II (2024) Thomas Stoneham-Judge "'Are you not entertained!?' - no, I'm not, but some people will be."
Posted Nov 27, 2024  Edit critic review
4.5/5
Flow (2024) Thomas Stoneham-Judge "It has a lot of great moments, it's beautiful to look at, and you can't not fall in love with these animals and their camaraderie."
Posted Nov 27, 2024  Edit critic review
5/5
Queer (2024) Thomas Stoneham-Judge "while [Daniel] Craig is good, I think his performance is elevated by the counterbalance of his co-star, Drew Starkey"
Posted Nov 27, 2024  Edit critic review
4.5/5
Saturday Night (2024) Thomas Stoneham-Judge This is the ensemble film of the year.
Posted Sep 28, 2024  Edit critic review
4.5/5
The Wild Robot (2024) Thomas Stoneham-Judge ...I’m sure [The Wild Robot] will be a new go-to animated film for families.
Posted Sep 27, 2024  Edit critic review
5/5
Hit Man (2023) Thomas Stoneham-Judge This is easily the best comedy of the year in my book...
Posted Jun 06, 2024  Edit critic review
2/5
Challengers (2024) Thomas Stoneham-Judge Tennis might be the sport of choice for this film, but simmering sexual tension is the name of the game, and this leading cast came to play. If only there was a more suitable arena to play in.
Posted Apr 26, 2024  Edit critic review
3/5
Civil War (2024) Thomas Stoneham-Judge ...[Alex Garland's] ability to curate suspense and unease remains exceptional...
Posted Apr 12, 2024  Edit critic review
4.5/5
Dune: Part Two (2024) Thomas Stoneham-Judge 'Dune Part Two' is another stunning sci-fi achievement from director Denis Villenueve.
Posted Feb 29, 2024  Edit critic review
5/5
The Taste of Things (2023) Thomas Stoneham-Judge It's a cinematic masterpiece - a literal feast for the eyes.
Posted Feb 15, 2024  Edit critic review
5/5
It's What's Inside (2024) Thomas Stoneham-Judge ...what I can confirm about "It’s What’s Inside" is that it is, in fact, abundantly enjoyable - likely the most fun film at Sundance this year.
Posted Jan 22, 2024  Edit critic review
4/5
Under the Influencer (2023) Thomas Stoneham-Judge And therein lies the true jewel of Under The Influencer: a brilliant acting talent occupying the lead role. Taylor Joree Scorse rises to the occasion with her portrayal of Tori...
Posted Nov 30, 2023  Edit critic review
4/5
TAYLOR SWIFT | THE ERAS TOUR (2023) Thomas Stoneham-Judge This movie is a remarkable gift to Taylor Swift fans.
Posted Oct 18, 2023  Edit critic review
4/5
The Creator (2023) Thomas Stoneham-Judge ...we have reached a new milestone in sci-fi filmmaking.
Posted Sep 28, 2023  Edit critic review
2.5/5
Finestkind (2023) Thomas Stoneham-Judge It is in this latter part of the film with a true villain materialized that 'Finestkind' establishes a gritty tone worth perking up for.
Posted Sep 23, 2023  Edit critic review
4/5
The Zone of Interest (2023) Thomas Stoneham-Judge ...it’s the film you hear that instills the horror and sense of monstrosity that enwraps 'The Zone Of Interest'.
Posted Sep 23, 2023  Edit critic review
4/5
Dumb Money (2023) Thomas Stoneham-Judge Dumb Money...certainly works well as a crowd pleasing film.
Posted Sep 23, 2023  Edit critic review
4.5/5
Mission: Impossible - Dead Reckoning Part One (2023) Thomas Stoneham-Judge ...[Mission Impossible] Dead Reckoning Part One is going to rank very high as one of the best action/thriller blockbuster experiences we will see in theaters this summer.
Posted Jul 10, 2023  Edit critic review
The Flash (2023) Thomas Stoneham-Judge ...[The Flash] is a notable step in the right direction as we prepare for a new era of DC movies.
Posted Jun 14, 2023  Edit critic review
1.5/5
The Boogeyman (2023) Thomas Stoneham-Judge ...'The Boogeyman' is likely to be one of the more forgettable and disappointing horror entries of the year...
Posted Jun 08, 2023  Edit critic review
Spider-Man: Across the Spider-Verse (2023) Thomas Stoneham-Judge I think it is storytelling and character development at its greatest.
Posted Jun 08, 2023  Edit critic review
4/5
Rye Lane (2023) Thomas Stoneham-Judge Rye Lane will stick with me as a thoroughly enjoyable film, and perhaps even the best rom-com of the year.
Posted Apr 01, 2023  Edit critic review
4.5/5
City of Dreams (2024) Thomas Stoneham-Judge As one who admires when one-takes and first person filming are utilized effectively in film, the way Dreamer is filmed is the type of packaging for this story that greatly appealed to me as a viewer.
Posted Mar 05, 2023  Edit critic review
2.5/5
Creed III (2023) Thomas Stoneham-Judge Despite my own dislike for the final product that 'Creed III' is...the film delivers on the cinematic components that audiences not only crave, but demand now more than ever from a blockbuster film like this.
Posted Mar 03, 2023  Edit critic review
4.5/5
Of an Age (2022) Thomas Stoneham-Judge Stolevski’s take on relationship drama remains compelling here in 'Of An Age'
Posted Feb 14, 2023  Edit critic review
Radical (2023) Thomas Stoneham-Judge Eugenio Derbez is astonishing in his role as Sergio.
Posted Feb 05, 2023  Edit critic review
5/5
Magazine Dreams (2023) Thomas Stoneham-Judge In addition to how Killian is developed in the script, his character is bolstered by an undeniably incredible performance from Jonathan Majors.
Posted Feb 05, 2023  Edit critic review
5/5
Past Lives (2023) Thomas Stoneham-Judge As the credits roll, viewers may find themselves with only one word floating through their minds then gently escaping their lips: “woah”.
Posted Feb 05, 2023  Edit critic review
Prev Next