Rotten Tomatoes
Movies Tv shows RT App News Showtimes
Publications list

Cool Girl Critiques

Cool Girl Critiques is not a Tomatometer-approved publication. Reviews from this publication only count toward the Tomatometer® when written by the following Tomatometer-approved critic(s): Alicia Gilstorf.

Prev Next
Rating Title | Year Author Quote
3/5
Ponyboi (2024) Alicia Gilstorf Ponyboi has good and bad parts to offer. And River Gallo’s performance as Ponyboi can easily be the sum of its best parts.
Posted Jun 28, 2025  Edit critic review
3.5/5
The Amateur (2025) Alicia Gilstorf The Amateur is a delightful foray into action for Malek. Even better, it’s an unexpectedly tender thriller with sharp action that uses psychological warfare to transcend mediocrity.
Posted May 14, 2025  Edit critic review
3.5/5
All of You (2024) Alicia Gilstorf A tender and heartbreaking portrait of love with the right person at the wrong time — this drama’s cynical and cathartic take on the soulmate trope will leave an emotional mark by its final frame.
Posted Nov 18, 2024  Edit critic review
4/5
Girl Haunts Boy (2024) Alicia Gilstorf Expertly mimicking the Disney Channel Original Movie formula, Girl Haunts Boy elevates its low-stakes love story with nostalgic storytelling beats and lived-in sets.
Posted Oct 20, 2024  Edit critic review
4.2/5
Caddo Lake (2024) Alicia Gilstorf This twisted M. Night Shyamalan-produced mystery thrives in the presence of its lead. O'Brien guides us through a story of family grief and loss with a soft chivalry that amplifies everything this subtle story has going for it.
Posted Oct 07, 2024  Edit critic review
3.5/5
Saturday Night (2024) Alicia Gilstorf Saturday Night channels The Bear’s tenacity with this bulldozing 90-minute biopic. It gives an unhinged white man free rein of the legendary comedy circus as Gabriel LaBelle’s Lorne leads a roaring symphony of stress, chaos, and mad genius.
Posted Sep 22, 2024  Edit critic review
3.5/5
Am I OK? (2022) Alicia Gilstorf Am I OK? is neither groundbreaking nor violently offputting. It just exists, and sometimes that's enough to be enjoyable. Sometimes, it is enough for this premise to strike a nerve.
Posted Jun 09, 2024  Edit critic review
3/5
Which Brings Me to You (2023) Alicia Gilstorf Ultimately, Which Brings Me to You is okay. Maybe even great at times. It holds its own even when the stench of heartbreak makes this romantic tale a little too dense to enjoy.
Posted Jan 30, 2024  Edit critic review
3/5
Sitting in Bars with Cake (2023) Alicia Gilstorf Whatever way you cut the cake, this film is a flavour profile of storytelling highs and lows until the very last bite.
Posted Sep 07, 2023  Edit critic review
3/5
Haunted Mansion (2023) Alicia Gilstorf A spooky adventure that will neither chill to the bone nor frighten with delight, Haunted Mansion is a harmless romp through the horrors of its amusement namesake.
Posted Aug 22, 2023  Edit critic review
Prev Next